Good morning everyone and a special hello to anyone visting from the train station canvass this morning. I have collated a variety of Lisbon information over the previous few posts, some of it my own materials, others sourced from a variety of places but all explaining why it is my view that a Yes vote is the only choice that makes sense when we vote on the treaty on the 2nd October. Have a read and feel free to drop a comment or come back to me with any views, questions or queries. James
Monthly Archives: September 2009
13 good reasons to say Yes
Why should we vote YES to the Lisbon Treaty?
1. Ratification ensures that each country keeps its commissioner. Under the previous Nice Treaty, each country would lose a commissioner to a proposed rotational system to be introduced in 2014. The Lisbon Treaty reverses this decision and provides that any changes to the number of commissioners beyond 2014 must be passed by a unanimous vote by the leaders of each country.
2. The Council of Ministers will meet in public. Up until now, they always met in private.
3. The EU Council will now be allowed to elect a president for a 2 and half year term. This new president won’t have any decision making powers however it will mean that we can put a face to Europe, especially at a global level. Also the country version will run over an 18 month term shared across three countries at a time, replacing the current system where the transition occurs every six months and to a single member.
4. The European Parliament will have new powers to overrule the EU Council’s decisions. The parliament will also now have joint control over the EU budget division. This will ensure greater accountability for the EU’s finances.
5. The Lisbon Treaty sets down concrete rules for new aspiring members (i.e. Turkey, Croatia, Ukraine etc.). Up until now, there were only vague guidelines for countries to adhere to before joining the EU.
6. The ECB will have more powers over its own monetary policy. This further separates politics from monetary issues which will ensure the survivability of the euro currency. Ireland’s membership to the euro currency at the moment is crucial to our own survivability. For instance, the rapid deterioration of the Icelandic currency in 2008 impoverished a once rich nation. If Ireland wasn’t a part of the euro currency in 2009, we possibly could have faced the same fate as Iceland.
7. The Lisbon Treaty gives Ireland (and other countries) opt-out clauses on certain matters. In Ireland’s case, we can opt-out of taxation and military defence directives.
8. The Charter of Fundamental Rights will be enshrined in EU law. This will ensure that all future EU laws are drafted to the highest moral and social standards. This will place the EU as the world leader in this area.
9. National parliaments (i.e. the Irish Dáil and Seanad) will now have 8 weeks to review and scrutinise all proposed EU legislation. A simple majority of national parliaments can scupper a legislative proposal from the commission without any further procedure should they so wish.
10. The Lisbon Treaty allows for the setup of a European Defence Agency. This will allow the EU to intervene in international crisis so that past atrocities in recent times are not repeated (e.g. the genocides in Srebrenica and Rwanda). If Ireland does not wish participate in certain missions because it feels that it may impinge on our neutrality, we have the option to opt-out.
11. A European Culture and Heritage Clause in Lisbon recognizes the influence of Judaeo-Christian tradition on EU laws and procedures. With Western Europes growing Islamic migrant populations, this clause gives legal security against the push for Sharia Law in some mixed-culture states.
12. Enhanced co-operation. This feature allows groups of countries within the EU to proceed with policies that other countries do not wish to participate in (e.g. tax harmonisation).
13. A new citizens’ petition clause in the Lisbon Treaty enables citizens’ groups across Europe to collect 1 million signatures to allow it force a bill efore the EU Parliament.
The Lisbon Treaty offers us a more efficient, transparent and democratic EU.
Please vote YES on 2nd October!
Blast from the past (Lisbon I arguments)
Here is what I had to say last time round. Most of this has actually been improved and copper fastened in the meantime.
Yes for the economy
Why Yes for the Economy?
In what ways does Ireland Need Europe?
1. Ireland needs Europe for Investment and Jobs
- Foreign investment sustains hundreds of thousands of Irish jobs.
- Ireland’s attractiveness as a destination for foreign investment stems directly from our positive approach to EU membership.
- The people who invest in Ireland, and who we need for job creation, all say that we need to vote Yes to Lisbon
2. Ireland needs Europe for Exports
- Ireland is the most export dependant country in the EU. 2 out of 3 jobs in Ireland depend on exports.
- As a member of the EU, Ireland has direct access to 500 million consumers.
- Prior to joining the EEC community in 1973, Britain was the main destination for Irish exports. Now 63% of all our exports go to the EU.
3. Ireland needs the Euro
- Ireland has gained greatly from having a leading international currency, the euro.
- The European Central Bank has been indispensable during the credit crunch.
How will voting Yes help our economy?
The most significant thing about the current crisis is how most of the challenges can’t be dealt with by countries acting alone. Unfortunately, the last year has seen the EU’s limitations in how or how fast it can act. As a small open economy, Ireland needs an EU which is more efficient and effective, especially at times like this.
How will voting Yes help to protect and create Jobs?
1. A Yes vote will improve business confidence by removing uncertainty and improving stability. This is key to stimulating domestic enterprise. That is why all the country’s business organisations are supporting a Yes vote.
2. A Yes vote will send out the right message to international investors. One of the reasons why companies set up here was that Ireland was viewed as a player in the EU, which was the best gateway for their business into the European market.
3. A Yes vote will commit the EU to the policy of achieving full employment when framing its economic policies. All economic policies that come from Europe will have to first and foremost be designed to create jobs.
4. A Yes vote will require the EU to develop renewable and sustainable energy sources. As one of the best placed countries in the EU to produce “green” energy, Ireland stand to gain from the creation of thousands of new jobs.
We’ll still be in the EU if we vote No, so it won’t impact on our economy?
- An EU which isn’t capable of acting fact even in the face of the largest economic crisis in 70 years is a bad thing for us.
- A lot of investment came to Ireland rather than other countries because we were seen as a Euro-positive country at the centre of decisions and developments.
- A No vote is a major risk – and there is no conceivable economic upside to a No vote.
What will happen to Ireland if there is a No vote?
It simply isn’t credible to say that there will be no impact on Ireland if we stand alone against a Treaty even if the issues of concern raised in our referendum have been answered.
- Many countries will start looking for other ways to increase their cooperation with each other. It would be very difficult for us to stop this ‘two-speed Europe’.
8 more reasons since last time round..
1. It’s a new proposal. Europe has listened to the Irish people, giving new guarantees on all of the main issues from last year. The Treaty is subject to these new guarantees. In over 50 years, the EU has fully honoured all such guarantees.
2. Only a Yes Vote will bring about a Reformed EU to tackle the Economic Crisis. A Union frozen in the past is of no use to anyone, but a Union which is more dynamic and effective is essential for our future.
3. Only a Yes Vote is Good for Investment: 90% of those who invest in Ireland and support hundred of thousands of jobs say that confidence in our position as a Euro-positive country matters a lot for them. Only a Yes will help maintain confidence at this difficult time.
4. Only a Yes Vote Saves Our Commissioner: A No vote means we could lose our Commissioner by November, and along with it we will lose our voice at the EU’s top table. In 2008, 80% of people were concerned about this issue. It has now been addressed.
5. Only a Yes Vote helps tackle Climate Change, insecure Energy Supplies, as well as helps to fight Cross-Border Criminals, Human Traffickers, and Drug Dealers. We cannot fight these problems on our own.
6. Only a Yes Vote is good for Workers and Social Protection: The Treaty gives legal effect to the rights, freedoms and principles as set out in the Charter of Fundamental Rights.
7. Only a Yes Vote ensures a more Democratic and Accountable EU: Lisbon makes a new oversight role for the Oireachtas, and increases the powers of the European Parliament
8. Only a Yes Vote will send a Vital Signal to our EU Partners and to International Investors that we are a Fully Engaged EU Country. The EU is a key part of our path to economic recovery. A more efficient EU is to our benefit.